Censorship of episodes released on DVD


DVD cuts

Breakthrough may finally solve the Edna Pearson problem!

September 30, 2009

On The Inside tells us FremantleMedia (who are slowly releasing Prisoner on DVD in the UK) are finally going to release the Edna Pearson episodes uncut in the UK, possibly in February 2010. Officially, Australian fans are being denied these episodes, but we have our ways of buying these DVDs when they come out, so stay tuned and keep an eye on your OTI mailing list inbox and website for further news on this long-awaited breakthrough!

May 3, 2008

A Prisoner fan and Recroom member reports that the Label Manager for Prisoner at Shock DVD has said the legal problems concerning the Edna Pearson episodes have only just been resolved.

"These episode were edited due to legal issues relating to a case that I believe has only just been resolved. We will be looking into redoing the episodes, but they are still some time off. In the future we may look at remastering them, but the quality present is difficult to bring up to DVD quality, as the original transfer we got access to was pretty shabby anyway.", he was quoted as saying in the email.

This was in a response to a query about the Spider Simpson episodes which appear to be confused with the Edna ones.

However, a Shock spokeswoman who has been answering a lot of queries about various issues recently has said there seems to be little hope that this "injunction" (which she knows less about than we do) will be scrapped, and so we are stuck with the mutilated versions on the official DVDs.

More details will be reported as soon as they come to hand.

How the Edna Pearson censor poisoned the DVD release

Episodes 463 through to 471, which are notorious for having suffered severe cuts because of Emily Perry back in 1984, did not escape the scissors for this DVD release as originally hoped. Despite warnings sent to Shock many months in advance, they still went ahead with authoring the cut versions of these episodes anyway, knowing fans would be unhappy with these versions, and on top of the storm of complaints over Episode 83 and the much smaller cuts littered here and there due to damage caused to the original tapes whilst in storage and in archiving over the past 20-odd years.

THE STORYLINE

The storyline — which the censors deem unsuitable for release on DVD — revolves around an old woman by the name of Edna May Pearson. In Episode 463, she is convicted of attempted murder, and sentenced to 18 months imprisonment, for trying to poison her husband Harry Pearson. She and her husband (who she tried to poison) work together to appeal against her sentence. All the inmates believe she is innocent, while the staff in particular prison cook Mrs O'Regan treat her as though she is guilty. She is banned from the kitchen. All the time as the women defend her innocence, Edna poisons several of her fellow inmates: Frances, Alice and Marlene, while they defend her innocence. Edna's appeal succeeds (468) and just when she is pardoned, she poisons the steak at the barbecue the women have to celebrate what they think is their last day of having an easy time of it in prison, before the Freak takes over as Governor. Bobbie cops the blame and is charged with the poisoning, but is eventually cleared after Meg finds new evidence which proves Edna is guilty, based on her knowledge about all the plants in the garden (469). Meanwhile, Rachel succeeds in getting a warning out that Edna is guilty, and this results in Edna and her husband separating as reported on the news as seen on TV by the women in the recroom (470). In Episode 471, even though the storyline had been "concluded" (Edna never seemed to return to jail and there didn't appear to be a retrial), there were still edits made in relation to Bobbie being cleared of the poisoning charge at the VJ's hearing.


This report outlines in detail the damage done to the affected episodes that were released on DVD as a result of the cuts made because of the "legal action" that relates to the events in 1984 involving Emily Perry (for more details on that, click here).

Volume 29, Disc 4 — EPISODE 463

This episode has 3 parts missing.

  1. Edna Pearson's induction is missing at 29:50, the point in Episode 463 on the DVDs between the scene where Marie Winter pushes Judy against the dryers and threatens to cause her pacemaker to fail and the gate slams, and the return to the laundry where Marlene and Rachel discuss aerobics and exercising. The missing scene is in reception, where Joyce Barry makes Edna May Pearson stand on the white line, and reads the charges out to her — that she has been convicted of attempted murder, and sentenced to 18 months imprisonment. Edna cries, says she is innocent, and asks why would she want to poison her husband?
  2. Edna Pearson is introduced to her fellow inmates, in the recroom. This part is missing from the point in the DVDs at 36:33, between Marlene Warren talking about a fashion parade, and Marlene back in her cell admitting to Heather Rodgers to sticking a sign on her back. Winter is the one who greets Edna "well well, this place is crawling with TV stars!" as she is led into the recroom by Officer Rodgers. Edna tells Judy Bryant she is not coping very well.
  3. Edna talking about her case with the women. Between the scene where the Freak advises Heather Rodgers not to mix with prisoners on a "social level" and that she agrees with her saying she is beginning to look like a clown, and the scene back at Meg's house where "Tracey"'s boyfriend is counting a wad of cash and Meg says it must be the proceeds of a robbery and "Tracey" says it was won at the TAB. The missing part, gone from 38:08, is in the recroom where Edna explains how her husband (who she allegedly tried to poison) is defending her innocence, and says her first husband was chronically ill and poisoned himself to end it all.

To see the report with clips and stills of the missing scenes, click here.

Running time: 41 minutes and 53 seconds (should be 45 minutes and 24 seconds)


Volume 29, Disc 4 — EPISODE 464

This episode has 2 parts missing:

  1. Part of a scene in the dining room at breakfast, where the women don't believe Edna looks like a poisoner, and pick another fight with Bobbie. (missing from the point at 11:15 on the DVD version of Episode 464)
  2. Gone from the point at 20:14 is a scene of Harry visiting Edna outside the building. This scene occurs between the scene in the laundry where Winter heavys Bryant again after a 'stunt' with the Freak, and before "Tracey" is at the airport booking a flight to Sydney.

To see the report with clips and stills of the missing scenes, click here.

Running time: 42 minutes and 34 seconds (should be 44 minutes and 26 seconds)


Volume 30, Disc 1 — EPISODE 465

The censor is getting busy now, taking out 7 parts from this episode:

  1. In the dining room at 2:28 between when Judy and Bobbie discuss Marlene and her mum, and when Winter says to Keane that it seems they put Marlene off her tucker. The censor considers the part — where Edna says to Rachel it is not easy in here, and asks her if she is hungry — unsuitable for Australian eyes.
  2. We are allowed to see Edna in her cell discussing with Rachel about how lucky she is to have Harry, and even mentioning the fact that she was appealing, but the scissors come out at 5:54 after Edna says Harry will move heaven and earth to make sure her appeal was successful, before she has a chance to say she was terribly upset when her first husband died..... What is the appeal about?
  3. Mrs O'Regan banning Edna from the kitchen because she is in for poisoning. (another 1 minute and 18 seconds goes missing, at 11:32)
  4. Edna in the Governor's office complaining about Mrs O'Regan banning her from the kitchen and denying she has ever poisoned anyone in her life, then back in the kitchen where Rachel and Marlene seriously doubt Edna could poison anyone, and can't understand why O'Regan kicked her out, then Marlene putting on an act of falling ill. The entire scene of the Governor's office and the kitchen are cut (another 3 minutes and 9 seconds missing at 12:41)
  5. In the recroom, the women listening to the transister as Edna's husband goes on radio appealing against her conviction of his attempted murder (57 seconds snipped at 20:40)
  6. Marlene looking at Edna's picture of Harry, and Edna accidentally saying how gullible Harry is, then in a panic asks Marlene whether she just heard what she said, before the gateslam at 22:01 (45 seconds go missing)
  7. We are allowed only some of the scene of Harry visiting Edna including Harry commenting on a dangerous plant having delicate flowers, but the gate slams right on cue at 31:12, just as the music associated with the banned storyline began to play — like as though the gateslam was locking that storyline away from us. (1 minute and 16 seconds go missing). The missing footage is of Edna asking him hesitantly if that is poisonous.

To see the report with clips and stills of the missing scenes, click here.

Running time: 37 minutes and 20 seconds (should be 45 minutes and 42 seconds)


Volume 30, Disc 1 — EPISODE 466

This episode suffers cuts on 5 occasions.

  1. At 8:39, footage of Edna telling Marlene she is her own brand of peppermint tea is missing, along with a few seconds of the beginning of the scene where Wally and Reynolds are arguing are also missing.
  2. At 10:11, footage of Marlene falling ill in the night, and complaining during morning muster, is cut.
  3. Winter joking in the laundry about one man's meat being another man's poison, is missing from 14:21
  4. Edna sneaking rat poison from the storeroom into her pocket, is cut from 20:54.
  5. Edna bringing Marlene cordial she says is from Harry and will settle her tummy, is cut from 23:25.
The people behind the cutting of the 'Edna Pearson episodes' have NO sense of humour!!

To see the report with clips and stills of the missing scenes, click here.

Running time: 38 minutes and 38 seconds (should be 43 minutes and 8 seconds, give or take a few seconds owing to gateslams that may also have gone missing)


Volume 30, Disc 1 — EPISODE 467

This episode has 8 parts missing.

  1. Edna telling Marlene how she knows what it is like to be unjustly imprisoned. Marlene looking for the barley water, missing from 17:26
  2. Joyce Barry getting Alice and Frances out of bed, finding them fallen ill: missing from 20:25
  3. A small part from the beginning of a scene in the dining room is missing from 22:27, where the women ask what's up with Alice and Frances.
  4. Marlene finding a bottle of barley water, missing from 26:20
  5. Marlene exercising in her cell, and telling Edna she has a "ginormous appetite", is missing from 31:07
  6. Alice and Frances heavying Marlene, accusing her of trying to kill them, then Marlene stopping Bobbie from drinking the barley water she thinks is poisoned, is missing from 33:13
  7. Judy telling Marlene she doesn't believe Edna would be poisoning anyone, is missing from 33:58
  8. Marlene accidentally knocking over and losing the evidence, and Judy telling her it's all in her imagination, is missing from 36:07

To see the report with clips and stills of the missing scenes, click here.

Running time: 38 minutes and 12 seconds (should be 46 minutes and 42 seconds)


Volume 30, Disc 1 — EPISODE 468

This episode has 3 parts missing.

  1. The Governor advising the Freak of her new roles should she become Governor, when she says Edna Pearson's appeal will be heard this afternoon, is missing from 32:49
  2. Edna poisoning the steak on the barbecue, Ann advising Meg in the staffroom of Edna's conviction being quashed, and Meg telling Edna the good news with the women cheering for her release, is missing from 37:47
  3. Marlene falling ill at the barbecue is missing from the end of the episode before the credits roll.

To see the report with clips and stills of the missing scenes, click here.

Running time: 40 minutes and 30 seconds (should be 44 minutes and 14 seconds)


Volume 30, Disc 2 — EPISODE 469

This is the worst-affected episode, with appalling cuts making it by far the shortest in the entire series. The butcher couldn't even leave the mugshots alone, with jumps in the music.

Also missing from this episode:

  1. Marlene in the infirmary, and trying to tell the Governor it was Edna. Rachel being given a hard time about her licence. Desmond telling the women Marlene is sick from food poisoning. All missing from 1:25
  2. Judy telling the Governor Bobbie is innocent, and the women in the recroom watching Edna's release on the TV news and trying to work out ways to prove it was Edna. Missing from 2:26
  3. Rachel saying she has to warn Edna's husband, as Bobbie begs for her innocence. Missing from 3:49
  4. Rachel and Judy trying in vain to warn the Governor about Edna and clear Bobbie's name. Missing from 4:43
  5. Myra telling Judy about Rachel finding Harry Pearson from the phone book and warning him. Missing from 7:27
  6. Marlene trying to get Alice and Frances to stop accusing Bobbie of poisoning them. Missing from 9:26
  7. Rachel saying she got in touch with Harry. Missing from 12:27
  8. Rachel tells Myra and Judy (who reckon it's a long shot coming from a prisoner) about getting in touch with Harry. Missing from 14:52
  9. The Freak accusing Meg of using prison time for personal business when she was on the phone explaining something about a garden, and Meg telling the Freak about how Edna knows all about the plants in the garden, including the poisonous ones. Ann going off at Joan for assuming office prematurely, is also missing from 24:33
  10. Part of Marlene telling Bobbie what she is writing in a letter to her parents, is missing from 29:22

To see the report with clips and stills of the missing scenes, click here.

Running time: 33 minutes and 32 seconds (should be 44 minutes and 45 seconds, give or take a few seconds)


Volume 30, Disc 2 — EPISODE 470

Mr Snippy hasn't finished his job yet — there was a TV news broadcast the women watched in the recroom that said Edna and her husband have separated due to "irreconcilable differences". The scene is missing from the DVDs at 35:07, straight after Judy telling Myra about her daughter's son being deaf, and before the boy yells for his dog down the drain as the waters continue to rise. More details.

Running time: 44 minutes and 36 seconds (should be 45 minutes and 23 seconds)


Volume 30, Disc 2 — EPISODE 471

Cuts to this episode weren't discovered until fairly recently. There were 3 more references to the poisoning case that also didn't escape the scissors. This episode was released on DVD twice — with the precise amount of footage missing from both versions even though the gateslams are shorter in the version on Disc 2 of Volume 30, than in the version contained in the Great Escapes disc in Box Set 2. There was a separate version of Episode 471 released in the USA version of Box Set 2, with the poisoning footage untouched, but the gateslams missing. This seems to suggest that (at least with this episode) it was redone from the master with the scenes already missing, while an uncut master is with an overseas affiliate.

Cuts to this episode:

  1. Part of the discussion in the recroom about the upcoming VJ hearing, where Bobbie is worried about being accused of poisoning, is missing from 6:15
  2. Part of Bobbie talking to Marlene about the VJ's hearing, is missing from 9:21
  3. Part of the VJ's hearing itself is also missing, from 28:53

To see the report with clips and stills of the missing scenes, click here.

Running time: 42 minutes and 49 seconds (should be at most 44 minutes and 11 seconds, but at least a fraction under 44 whole minutes)


Another detailed report on the butchery to these episodes (when they were shown on TV) can be found here.

STAND UP FOR YOUR RIGHTS!

These cuts were made due to "legal issues" that for reasons still unknown still exist 23 years after the case. We are told that the DVD release has to stay within this undocumented law, we can complain all we like, and there is no way around this — but there are avenues we can take to try to remedy this situation and put pressure on them if we really want these episodes officially released on DVD uncut. We could demand the full publication of official documentation of the "legal action" that still requires these episodes to be cut, and depending on the validity of any such documentation, seek intervention from consumer affairs watchdogs and the Ombudsman, and in the end have replacements for the discs mentioned above, with the original, uncut versions of these episodes included.

 


Last updated October 18, 2009